18+ only

Scenes/My Dad's Hot Girlfriend/Natalia Starr & Johnny Castle – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2013)

Natalia Starr & Johnny Castle – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2013)

Natalia Starr and Johnny Castle star in this 2013 My Dad's Hot Girlfriend scene from Naughty America.

Natalia Starr & Johnny Castle – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2013), picture 1 of 4

Cast

Johnny CastleNatalia Starr

About this scene

Natalia Starr and Johnny Castle also appear together in: Natalia Starr & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2025), Natalia Starr & Johnny Castle – I Have a Wife (2014), Natalia Starr & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2013).

Previous My Dad's Hot Girlfriend release: Rilynn Rae & Johnny Castle – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2013). Next: Stacey Foxxx & Bruno Dickemz – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2013).

More like this

This scene's DNA: 21 traits from the studio's tags. Brighter means rarer. The scenes below share the most of its rarer traits.
▶ Trailer28 min sceneEsperanza Gomez & Chris Johnson – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2024)My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · 2 Jun 20241 place to watch

65% match · Dad's Girlfriend · My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · Foreign Accent

▶ Trailer30 min sceneAlexis Adams & Anthony Rosano – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2025)My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · 29 Jun 20251 place to watch

65% match · Dad's Girlfriend · My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · Big natural tits

▶ Trailer32 min sceneJesse Pony & Max Fills – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2025)My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · 26 Feb 20251 place to watch

63% match · Dad's Girlfriend · My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · Hairy Pussy

30 min sceneKeisha Grey & JMac – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2017)My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · 25 May 20171 place to watch

62% match · Dad's Girlfriend · My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · Big natural tits

VR 180°27 min sceneAnissa Kate, Cherry Kiss & Dan Damage – 2 Chicks Same Time (2023)2 Chicks Same Time · 28 Apr 20231 place to watch

61% match · Foreign Accent · European · Big natural tits

Anissa Kate, Jessie Volt & Tyler Nixon – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2014)My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · 27 Jun 20141 place to watch

60% match · Dad's Girlfriend · My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · Foreign Accent

Nikita Von James, Summer Brielle & Seth Gamble – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2014)My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · 2 May 20141 place to watch

59% match · Dad's Girlfriend · My Dad's Hot Girlfriend · Foreign Accent

▶ Trailer35 min sceneTexas Patti & Rion King – My Friend's Hot Mom (2018)My Friend's Hot Mom · 13 Nov 20181 place to watch

58% match · Foreign Accent · European · Hairy Pussy

More from this cast

4 picsSarah Vandella & Johnny Castle – Naughty Office (2026) · photosJohnny Castle, Sarah VandellaNaughty Office4 picsDiamond Foxxx, Chad White & Johnny Castle – Dirty Wives Club (2026) · photosChad White, Diamond Foxxx, Johnny CastleDirty Wives Club4 picsAsa Akira, Juelz Ventura & Johnny Castle – 2 Chicks Same Time (2026) · photosAsa Akira, Johnny Castle, Juelz Ventura2 Chicks Same Time4 picsAudrey Bitoni, Katie Kox & Johnny Castle – My Girlfriend's Busty Friend (2026) · photosAudrey Bitoni, Johnny Castle, Katie KoxMy Girlfriend's Busty Friend4 picsSarah Jessie & Johnny Castle – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2026) · photosJohnny Castle, Sarah JessieMy Dad's Hot Girlfriend4 picsAshley Lane, Katie Kush & Kenzie Madison – Office (2026) · photosAshley Lane, Johnny Castle, Katie Kush, Kenzie MadisonOffice4 picsJulia Ann & Johnny Castle – My Girl Loves Anal (2026) · photosJohnny Castle, Julia AnnMy Girl Loves Anal4 picsNatalia Starr & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2025) · photosJohnny Castle, Natalia StarrMy Sister's Hot Friend

Follow @PornSleuth on X for new scenes daily