18+ only

Scenes/My Sister's Hot Friend/Nikki Benz & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2014)

Nikki Benz & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2014)

Nikki Benz and Johnny Castle star in this 2014 My Sister's Hot Friend scene from Naughty America.

Nikki Benz & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2014), picture 1 of 4

Nikki Benz was over at her friend's place to use their pool. Her friend's brother was staked out in the pool house, rubbing one out and got busted, Brad Hamilton style. Lucky for him, Nikki was overwhelmed with horniness and had to get that cock between her thighs!

Cast

Johnny CastleNikki Benz

About this scene

Nikki Benz and Johnny Castle also appear together in: Nikki Benz & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2006).

Previous My Sister's Hot Friend release: Brooklyn Chase & Johnny Sins – My Sister's Hot Friend (2014). Next: Aaliyah Love, Tasha Reign & Tyler Nixon – My Sister's Hot Friend (2014).

More like this

This scene's DNA: 22 traits from the studio's tags. Brighter means rarer. The scenes below share the most of its rarer traits.
▶ Trailer39 min sceneSarah Jessie & Tyler Nixon – Naughty Office (2018)Naughty Office · 22 Jul 20181 place to watch

79% match · Hazel Eyes · Outie Pussy · Petite

▶ Trailer40 min sceneBianca Burke & Seth Gamble – Dirty Wives Club (2019)Dirty Wives Club · 15 Sep 20191 place to watch

77% match · Hazel Eyes · Outie Pussy · Ass Licking

Jessie Rogers & Rikki Six – My Sister's Hot Friend (2012)My Sister's Hot Friend · 31 Oct 20121 place to watch

77% match · Hazel Eyes · Sister's Friend · Petite

▶ Trailer25 min sceneBailey Brooke & Damon Dice – My Sister's Hot Friend (2017)My Sister's Hot Friend · 13 Jun 20171 place to watch

76% match · Hazel Eyes · Sister's Friend · Petite

▶ Trailer28 min sceneSarah Jessie & Richie Black – My Friend's Hot Mom (2017)My Friend's Hot Mom · 3 Jun 20171 place to watch

75% match · Hazel Eyes · Outie Pussy · Athletic

▶ Trailer39 min sceneMelrose Foxxx & Seth Dickens – Ass Masterpiece (2024)Ass Masterpiece · 7 Apr 20241 place to watch

74% match · Hazel Eyes · Petite · Ass Licking

▶ Trailer41 min sceneBrandi Love, Lexi Belle & Madison Ivy – Naughty Office (2024)Naughty Office · 29 Sep 20241 place to watch

72% match · Hazel Eyes · Petite · Ass Licking

▶ Trailer36 min sceneNina Elle & Tyler Nixon – My Friend's Hot Mom (2017)My Friend's Hot Mom · 24 Jul 20171 place to watch

72% match · Hazel Eyes · Outie Pussy · Ass Licking

More from this cast

4 picsSarah Vandella & Johnny Castle – Naughty Office (2026) · photosJohnny Castle, Sarah VandellaNaughty Office4 picsDiamond Foxxx, Chad White & Johnny Castle – Dirty Wives Club (2026) · photosChad White, Diamond Foxxx, Johnny CastleDirty Wives Club4 picsAsa Akira, Juelz Ventura & Johnny Castle – 2 Chicks Same Time (2026) · photosAsa Akira, Johnny Castle, Juelz Ventura2 Chicks Same Time4 picsAudrey Bitoni, Katie Kox & Johnny Castle – My Girlfriend's Busty Friend (2026) · photosAudrey Bitoni, Johnny Castle, Katie KoxMy Girlfriend's Busty Friend4 picsSarah Jessie & Johnny Castle – My Dad's Hot Girlfriend (2026) · photosJohnny Castle, Sarah JessieMy Dad's Hot Girlfriend4 picsAshley Lane, Katie Kush & Kenzie Madison – Office (2026) · photosAshley Lane, Johnny Castle, Katie Kush, Kenzie MadisonOffice4 picsJulia Ann & Johnny Castle – My Girl Loves Anal (2026) · photosJohnny Castle, Julia AnnMy Girl Loves Anal4 picsNatalia Starr & Johnny Castle – My Sister's Hot Friend (2025) · photosJohnny Castle, Natalia StarrMy Sister's Hot Friend

Follow @PornSleuth on X for new scenes daily